|
Growth hormones in veal spark debate FDA says
they're illegal, but industry says they're not new
Copyright
2004 Gannett Company, Inc.
USA TODAY
April 2, 2004, Friday through Sunday, FIRST EDITION
Revelations
that up to 90% of U.S. veal calves are being fed synthetic
testosterone illegally are sending a shock wave through the meat
industry,
causing a government crackdown and new worries about the impact
of hormones on the food supply. In interviews with USA TODAY, veal
industry officials said that calves have been fed growth hormones
for decades. Officials with the Food and Drug Administration, however,
say this has never been legal and the safety of this practice has
not been tested.
Since last
Friday, the Department of Agriculture has been stopping veal
calves found to have hormone implants from entering the food supply.
Its
action was prompted by a USDA veterinarian's discovery of a
hormone-releasing implant in a Wisconsin calf. About 700,000 veal
calves are slaughtered each year at 20 weeks of age. The hormone
is trenbolone acetate, which is legally used to increase growth
in adult cattle but is not approved for use in calves. "We
consider this an illegal activity," says Stephen Sundlof, who
heads the FDA's Center for Veterinary Medicine. He said the drug
may be metabolized differently in calves than in adult animals.
But Paul
Slayton of the American Veal Association called the issue much ado
about nothing, saying hormones have been fed to calves for 30 years.
It is unknown
if the hormone is harmful to people who eat veal. It is also
not known exactly how many calves are being held back as suppliers
await a possible compromise with the FDA, which may come as soon
as this weekend. Both the USDA and FDA are involved because the
USDA monitors food safety and the FDA regulates drugs given to animals.
The USDA
confirms that veal processing is way down, a fact echoed by the
nation's largest veal processor. "Nobody's sending any animals
in," says
Wayne Marcho of Marcho Farms in Harleysville, Pa.
It is too
soon to know how this will affect prices or when stores and
restaurants may feel a shortage.
When the
USDA discovered the problem last week, it was believed to affect
only a small number of animals. But Sen. Arlen Specter, R-Pa., said
Tuesday in a letter to FDA acting Director Lester Crawford that
"more than 90% of all veal calves grown in the United States
utilize a growth implant."
Industry officials interviewed Thursday put the usage at 80% to
90%.
The veal
industry is trying to get the FDA to stay enforcement of its rules
for at least two months, so that the calves can be slaughtered and
sold to
restaurants and supermarkets. Pennsylvania is a big veal-producing
state,
and Specter said that the USDA and FDA were "likely to jeopardize
the entire veal industry."
The veal
industry is being criticized by other meat producers. The practice
is "simply wrong," says Gary Weber of the National Cattlemen's
Beef
Association.
|